Restore vs Upcycle; What Story Will Your Piece Tell

Have you ever refinished a piece of furniture?
If you have followed along my painting journey, you will know that I LOVE taking something that is deemed as trash and bringing it back to life.  Sometimes that means upcycling a piece and sometimes it means restoring a piece.

Restore vs Upcycle

Restoring means to take something and honour it’s past by bringing it back to life, thus bringing up its worth and value.

Upcycling means to take something that is basically sad, dead or worthless and turn it into something new.  Usually that something new will be something other than it’s intended original purpose.

Both restoring and upcyling have their place; sometimes a piece is begging to have its story heard while  other times a piece is longing for a new life.

This piece, that I found at the dump store (check out a few other cool things I have found there… here and here and here ) this summer, was crying to be restored. 
vintage dresser rescued from dumpThe top was incredibly damaged buuut I could see that there was some beautiful wood living under that flaking, chipping finish.  Wood that was just begging to brought back to life.   And, not only was the wood gorgeous but the dresser had its original wheels and hardware! badly damaged vintage dresser topThis dresser, even though it was in pretty sad shape, still had a lot of life in it as a dresser.  It just needed cleaning and a little paint.  It didn’t need to be turned into something else, it was perfectly great as a dresser. Silver Lake in Eastern Ontario, CanadaWhen I found the dresser, I could have spent time turning it into something else, like a bookshelf or TV stand, but this dresser was so pretty that I just wanted to continue on as it was. vintage Ironstone and vintage doily

Restoring the piece… 

To restore the gorgeous wood on the top of the dresser, I sanded it down and applied two coats of General Finishes Gel Stain in Java.  To seal it and create a beautiful finish, it got two coats of General Finishes Gel Top Coatvintage copper hardwareFor the paint, I used Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint in French Enamel and let it chip and flake as it wanted.  I absolutely love how milk paint chips and flakes at will.  It always helps to recreate that authentically old look. Miss Mustard Seed Milk Paint on a vintage dresser all chippy and beautifulAs for that stunning copper hardware?  All it got was a cleaning with good old soap and water.  It was beautiful just as it was.  painted drawers inside a vintage dresserLike all of my furniture pieces, I painted the inside of the drawers.  They always feel so clean and fresh to me with a new coat of paint.  These were painted with two coats of Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint in Ironstone.  a vintage dresser recreated with Miss Mustard Seed Milk paintI feel like I have done this beautiful piece justice by restoring the beauty I know she always had.
What do you think?
Would you have restored her or upcycled her into something completely different?  (ps – there’s no right answer… you just do what speaks to you!) vintage dresser finished with Miss Mustard Seed's Milk paint and General Finishes gel stain

**Please note that this post includes Affiliate links for your convenience.  All links are for products that I have tried and use regularly.  By using the link, it in no way increases the cost of the item to you should you choose to purchase.  However, by using the link, a small portion of the sale is given back to help fund this blog. Thank you! **

Pin for later… restore, don't just upcycle vintage furniture

Happy painting!

I have 2 lovely thoughts, I'd love to hear yours

  1. This is so crazy gorgeous Lisa! It honestly doesn’t even look like the same piece. You know I am loving all that chippy goodness and the color is stunning. I’m always inspired by your painted pieces and techniques. Everything is really beautiful. Hugs, CoCo

I'd love to hear what you think...